Saturday, October 6, 2012

Townhouses: maybe not a solution to housing woes, but a much needed option

A couple of years ago, I woke up on my birthday to find a mean spirited op-ed in the Vancouver Sun criticizing my attitude towards socially mixed communities. I was not happy.

I was therefore much happier, on this my 65th birthday, to come across another newspaper article, this time by Gary Mason in the Globe and Mail, mentioning me and addressing a topic near and dear to my heart; building more affordable housing choices in Vancouver.

Elsewhere in the newspapers, Shelley Fralic has written a Vancouver Sun op-ed and there's a Letter to the Editor suggesting that rather than potentially ruin Vancouver by trying to build affordable housing, why not simply let people move elsewhere.  I am not unsympathetic to the argument that those seeking affordable housing move elsewhere, noting that New Westminster and the Tri-Cities and Surrey, etc are beginning to create very attractive communities.  Similarly, smaller towns like Trail and Nelson offer attractive choices for those who can't afford Vancouver.

However, I still maintain that Vancouver needs to create additional housing choices, both for those seeking more affordable housing, and the many longstanding residents like me who may soon wish to downsize while remaining in their neighbourhoods, and want to see their children living in the City as well.

For these reasons I participated in the Mayor's Task Force on Affordable Housing, chairing a Roundtable that looked at Building Form and Design, and am a defender of many of the ideas now being put forward by the Task Force and City Council. I look forward to the coming years as more townhouses and stacked townhouses are built in the City, for those of us who are not yet ready for an apartment, but either unable to afford, or not wanting to live in a single family house.

Here's Gary Mason's article on the topic:


Opinion: Townhouses not the solution to Vancouver’s housing woes

Of all the recommendations in the report from the city of Vancouver’s housing affordability task force, the one that received the most attention is the least likely to drive down costs – thin streets.
Thin streets is the concept whereby the city splits a standard, 66-foot-wide road in two
to allow the construction of new homes along one half. An example of what this would look like received wide distribution around the release of the task force’s review.
And what it looked like was this: the extra 33 feet being used to build homes that appeared,
in size and structure, very much like the older ones that would exist beside them. Homes that are worth (sometimes well) in excess of $1-million.  So what is the likelihood that the new homes – thanks to the city splitting a street in half –are going to be any cheaper than homes already in the neighbourhood?
If anything, Given the fact that they new homes would be, well, newer with all the modern amenities, they are likely to be even more expensive.

An affordability game changer thin streets is not. Which is why it’s unfortunate that the idea became such a talking point and, for a while, commandeered the discussion of the task force’s work. Still, Mayor Gregor Robertson and his Vision Vancouver government deserve credit for attempting to address the affordability crisis in this city, as futile as that effort may ultimately be.

There is also a lot of talk in the report, for instance, of the need for more options like townhouses, which take up less space and are generally considered to be a cheaper alternative for home buyers. But, of course, when you are talking about real estate in Vancouver, the term “cheaper” is always relative.

In the past couple of years, a few townhouse projects have sprouted up along Oak Street. Many of the units were being sold for prices that reached into the high $900,000s and, often, north of $1-million. So I’m not sure how anyone thinks more townhouses are going to be the answer to affordability.

Even if you build stacked townhouses, effectively townhouses on top of townhouses, it’s still going to cost well over $700,000 per unit just about anywhere in the city. Yes, that’s less expensive than those townhouses along Oak Street, but I’m not sure you could ascribe the term “affordable” to them. Are these the places that are supposed to open the doors to first-time home buyers? The government considers housing as affordable if it consumes less than 30 per cent of household income. Given that in 2010, the median household income in Vancouver was just over $67,000, I don’t see how more townhouses are going to reduce the financial stress on families trying to get into the market.

Architect and developer Michael Geller, the mind behind some of the more imaginative and successful multiunit real estate projects in Metro Vancouver and who was a consultant on the task force report, agrees that townhouses in the city of Vancouver aren’t affordable by most measures at the moment. But he believes prices will come down as more of that type of housing is built.

“When they’re the only buildings of that type around, a developer can pretty much set his own price,” Mr. Geller told me. “But once you build more of it and there is a competition in the market place, then you generally see prices start to come down. I think that’s what we’ll see here.”

I’m not sure I’m buying it, but it’s worth a try. The alternative is for the city to throw up its hands and say it can do nothing about the affordability dilemma. So in an attempt to mitigate the problem, it has decided to rezone designated areas to make way for six-storey apartment buildings. And perhaps a swack of townhomes, and row and stacked housing and carriage houses in every laneway will help, too. Any relief would be welcome.

Now, the city just has to fight off the small army of residents that is forming to oppose any change in their neighbourhoods. This, too, was expected, and some people will likely be extremely unhappy at the end of this process – but that comes with making change in the name of the greater good.
The mayor’s task force may have created a blueprint for more housing in Vancouver. Whether it will ever be considered affordable is another matter entirely.

Friday, October 5, 2012

Further observations on the Affordable Housing Task Force recommendations

The following Letter to the Editor appeared in today's Vancouver Sun:

Increasing supply of housing won’t help affordability
Re: ‘ Thin streets’ could boost affordability, Sept. 27
Why would the addition a few houses in an expensive city make housing more affordable? It hasn’t happened in other cities.
How can the city take away someone’s corner lot and plunk another house beside it, or a row of townhouses, completely out of step with the existing neighbourhood?
The resulting “thin” street would be dangerously narrow, making it difficult for emergency vehicles and local traffic to get through. And, of course, one lane of parking will disappear, another assault on the automobile.
Open street spaces are very welcome and much needed, what with the continued encroachment of larger homes and laneway houses.
We’ve just been subjected to a task force led by developers and we know what their goals are. B. K. GOODSON Vancouver

I completely disagree with the headline, and the writer's final statement, but do share his concerns regarding the likely benefits of the 'Thin Streets' idea.

I mentioned to some Task Force members and City staff, that the Thin Street proposition, (that came from the ReThink Housing Competition organized by the City rather than from either the Task Force  or the Roundtable on Form and Design) has unfortunately hijacked many of the very good recommendations of the Task Force. 

While the Thin Streets idea is intriguing, I do not forsee widespread application of it for various reasons. It has negative impacts on corner lot owners, takes away greenery and in some case important north-south views, and could be more expensive than the proponents anticipate to relocate roads, street lights, sidewalks, other services, etc.

In some instances I could see how it might result in additional lots that might be developed with more than one unit, or combined with the corner lot to allow a small townhouse or stacked development as illustrated above.

That being said, I strongly disagree with the suggestion that more housing supply will not impact affordability. It will.

Currently, there are very few undeveloped sites zoned for townhouse or stacked townhouse developments. However, these forms of housing would provide more affordable housing choices in the city.  Now some might ask, why will they be more affordable when the recent townhouse developments along Oak Street and Cambie street are quite expensive. That's because the developers had little competition, and in some cases had to pay significant Community Amenity Contributions to the City, tied to the increase in land value resulting from the rezoning.

If there were hundreds of sites available for alternate forms of housing, as contemplated by our suggestion of creating 'transition zones' behind arterials, and multi family housing along arterials away from the commercial cores, and if Community Amenity Contributions were fixed at pre-determined and reasonable levels, I am confident that more supply will result in more affordable housing.

Now as for the suggestion that the Task Force was "led by developers" and that's why we're seeing ideas like the Thin Streets, this is simply wrong. Yes, Co-chair Olga Illich is a developer, and there were  developers on the Task Force, and I am involved in development as well as architecture and planning, the developers were at a minority in this process. Moreover I can say that none of the developers I know advocated for the Thin Streets idea. This idea came from two former City and Metro Planners, and was promoted by City staff and Council...not builders or developers.

In summary, I do believe that the decisions made by Council this week will ultimately lead to increased housing supply and increased affordability.  It will take time, but five years from now, young couples and empty nesters will be able to buy and rent forms of housing that are not often being built today.

However, I won't be surprised if only a very small number of these homes will be on newly created corner lots.  If any!

Tuesday, October 2, 2012

Some observations re the Thin Streets Proposal

Thin streets have Vancouver corner lot owners worried

Metro/Kate Webb Kitsilano homeowner David Grigg is worried about losing light on his corner property if the city moves ahead with thin streets.
Vancouver councillors and homeowners grilled deputy city manager David McLellan Tuesday about the affordable housing task force’s proposed thin streets concept.
The 17-member task force recommended six priority actions and nine additional actions in its final report released last week, which was the result of 10 months of study and public consultations.
But not everyone is happy with its recommendation that the city immediately begin pilot projects to create parcels of land for more ground-oriented housing by thinning certain residential streets. Kitsilano homeowner David Grigg said he and his wife bought a unit in a raised bungalow 20 years ago precisely because of its location.
“All of us are petrified at losing our light,” he said, addressing McLellan directly outside council chambers. “If a thin street were put in place, some of the treescape would disappear. It has to.”
McLellan did his best to assure Grigg that no one would be forced into anything if the task force’s recommendations were to go ahead, and all standard rezoning procedures, including hearings, would still apply.
“There would be a public process around any of these sorts of things, and the neighbourhood impact is a very important consideration for council,” he said.
NPA Coun. Elizabeth Ball questioned McLellan about how corner lot property values would be affected by thin streets — a concern she said she has heard repeatedly from constituents.
McLellan referred her to two solutions put forward by Vancouver housing and development expert and one-time NPA candidate Michael Geller.
Geller has suggested corner lot owners who agree to let new homes be built beside them could be rewarded with the opportunity to rezone their own lots for up to three units, allowing them to unlock some of the equity in their land while creating even more housing stock.
Otherwise, Geller said corner lot owners should be given an easy out:
“If the people on the corner lot said, ‘hell no, we don’t want to be here,’ perhaps the city could acquire or facilitate a developer acquiring their lot and then the city could combine the two lots into one, and that would be big enough to put townhouses on.”
While Geller said he thinks the thin streets concept is a good idea, he added he is skeptical it will take off on a wide scale because of problems with rerouting underground sewage and water lines.
There are 16 speakers registered to address city council and staff Wednesday before council votes on whether to adopt the task force’s 15 recommendations. Anyone who wishes to speak can register up until 10 minutes before the agenda resumes at 9:30 a.m. Wednesday.

The Mayor's Task Force on Affordable Housing.

This mornng, Vancouver City Council will consider a staff report making a number of recommendations based on the Task Force report.  As Chair of a Roundtable that reported to the Task Force on the impacts of regulations related to Building Form and Design, I am most interested in the next steps in this process.  Unfortunately, based on conversations I have had with many people, and Letters to the Editor of today's Vancouver Sun, it is apparent that there is considerable misunderstanding regarding what is being contemplated. This is particularly true for the recommendation related to 'Thin Streets' which was not a recommendation of either my Roundtable or the Task Force. I will write further on this and other matters after the Council deliberations. However, in the meanwhile, below is the covering letter from my report which sets out a number of ideas that I am happy to see incorporated in the final Task Force Report.
March 22, 2012

Mayor Gregor Robertson and Ms. Olga Ilich,

Co-chairs, Mayor’s Task Force on Affordable Housing, City of Vancouver,
453 West 12th Avenue,
Vancouver, BC V5Y 1V4, Canada

Dear Mayor Robertson and Ms. Ilich,
re: Preliminary findings of Roundtable on Building Form and Design
As Chair of the Roundtable on Building Form and Design, I am pleased to submit this preliminary report to assist the Task Force in its deliberations. As requested, we have attempted to identify zoning and building code requirements and other design regulations that may be unnecessarily adding to the cost of affordable housing.
When I first agreed to participate in this Task Force initiative, a number of people questioned whether any positive benefits would be forthcoming. They noted that many of the factors contributing to the cost of housing in Vancouver, such as the high cost of land and the impacts of foreign investment, are beyond the mandate of the City. However, as  I believe you will note from this report, there is much that the City can do to improve its zoning and building regulations to encourage the creation of a variety of more affordable housing forms. For instance, by modifying the RS zoning, it will be possible to facilitate the development of smaller, more affordable single family, duplex, semi-detached and coach house homes.


By creating new ‘transition’ zones, it will be possible for the City to encourage a broader range of more affordable rowhouse, townhouse and stacked-townhouse units. As you know, I am particularly keen to see more ‘fee-simple’ rowhouses developed in the City.
By undertaking revisions to the RT (two-family) and C-2 zones, it will be possible to facilitate an increased supply of more livable housing located close to transit and other amenities.
By reconsidering parking standards and regulations, minimum suite sizes, and changes to fire regulations and accessibility standards, additional savings can be realized.
While the City has achieved a high level of recognition for its zoning, planning and discretionary design requirements, many people believe the competing demands from various city departments are contributing to a very complex approval process and higher housing costs. They would like to see the same level of commitment to affordability that is currently being devoted to sustainability. In this regard, it is suggested that the City consider appointing an Ombudsman to adjudicate the design conflicts that often arise due to the different values and requirements of City departments.
Finally, while many may question whether reduced costs will translate into reduced prices, I am confident that by facilitating an increased housing supply and greater competition
in the marketplace, cost reductions resulting from many of the suggested measures will ultimately translate into lower prices and more affordable housing choices for the residents of Vancouver.
Respectfully submitted,
Michael Geller, B.Arch, MAIBC, FCIP
Chair, Roundtable on Building Form and Design

The full report can be found here  http://vancouver.ca/files/cov/HousingAffordability-DiscussionDraft-Gellers-BuildingFormDesign.pdf

Monday, September 17, 2012

Notifications for new development proposals

There's a good op-ed article in today's Vancouver Sun http://t.co/mGfJb7e3 about the need to redesign boring legal notifications in the internet age. The fact is, people can make a difference, if only they know what's going on. With this in mind, the municipality of Pemberton redesigned its legal notifications for upcoming development proposals.  Here is the improved notice which won an award from the Planning Instititute of BC.

Thursday, September 13, 2012

Penthouse for Rent at SFU's UniverCity



I bought this 1250+ sq ft two bedroom and den penthouse at the end of 2006 since I wanted to have a souvenir of my seven years at SFU! It's also the highest apartment in all of Metro Vancouver!  And it's for rent...if you know someone who might be interested, have them call the agent...or me!  Thanks

http://westwoodridge.vflyer.com/home/flyer/home/180713015
If you don't see the link, or if you click on the link and it appears broken, please copy and paste the URL into a new browser window.
UNIVERCITY PENTHOUSE!! - STUNNING LOWERMAINLAND VIEWS!! 2 Bed, 2 Bath and Den - SFU - Altaire
Main Photo
Location: SFU - Univercity
This gorgeous open plan 2 bed and Den suite is located in Polygon's Altaire Highrise building.

**Available October 1st 2012**

Please call Rob at  604-871-4478  or email info@westwoodridge.net

Features Include:

- Breathtaking water views from large oversized private balcony
- Corner suite with floor to ceiling windows with city and water views
- Laminate wood flooring in living and dining areas
- Large kitchen island with granite countertops in kitchen and ensuite washroom
- Cozy electric fireplace in living room
- Upgraded stainless steel appliances
- Large walk-in closets in master bedroom
- Only a few minutes walk to SFU
- Includes one underground parking stall (2nd stall available)
- Secured underground storage unit
- Access to full service gym facilities located within the building
- Gas and hot water are included
Information
Pricing
Rent: CAD 2,450 per month
Available Date: Mon Oct 01, 2012
Deposit: $1225
Minimum Lease: One Year
Included Utilities: Gas and Hot Water
Property Location
9188 University Crescent
Burnaby, BC V5A 0A5
View Map
Features
Bedrooms: 2.5
Bathrooms: 2
Located on Floor #: 15
Floors in Bldg: 15
Square Footage: 1300
Parking Spaces: 1
Property Type: Condo
Year Built: 2009
School District: Burnaby
Agent Name: Rob Smallwood
Broker: Westwood Ridge Development Corporation
Attributes
Rental Unit Amenities
Refrigerator
Dishwasher
Washer/Dryer
Fireplace
Hardwood Floors
Balcony
View
Building Amenities
On-site Manager
Exercise Room
Other Amenities
Additional Storage
Guest Parking
Hardwood Floors
Microwave
Photo Gallery

Tuesday, September 4, 2012

Rising in the East: Contemporary New Towns in Asia

Often on Tuesdays I join a small group of Vancouverites at the Roundtable, a luncheon discussion group that has been meeting since the 30's. Today I sat with former City Councillor Sandra Wilking and Vancouver Sun journalist Daphne Bramham and the topic of planning in China came up during our discussion. Sandra was describing Tianjin Eco-City, a remarkable new town being developed by PRC and Singapore and I was reminded of the fascinating experiences I had in two new towns in Songjiang New City, outside of Shanghai during my visit to EXPO 2010.

One is called Thames Town and was patterned on an old English town.  The other, Anting was designed to look like a contemporary German town.

Both towns are described in a wonderful book I came across in Almere at the International New Town Institute. It is called Rising in the East: Contemporary New Towns in Asia and includes dozens of photos that have to be seen to be believed. http://www.sunarchitecture.nl/books/category/urbanism/rising_in_the_east_9789461056832?lang=en

Many of these new towns have been designed by international firms, including some from Canada. In the case of Songjiang, nine of them are themed based on other places around the world. In addition to the English and German towns, there is also a Dutch town that looks quite Dutch!

Thames Town was mostly vacant when I was there in 2010, other than for the dozens of brides and grooms who were using the town as a setting for their wedding photos.  Anting seemed a bit more occupied, altho many of the contemporary facades were being torn down and rebuilt. Sadly, the buildings were surrounded by drywall rubble despite the fact that the buildings were quite new.

When I commented on the number of Volkswagens parked along the streets I was told there was in fact a large VW plant nearby.  As Tom Friedman has often said, the world is flat!

Here are a few photos of Anting 












When I was in Thames Town my mouth started to water when I passed the Thamestown, a neighbourhood B&B and pub.  I offered to take my hosts inside for a steak and kidney pie and a pint of Palmers bitter...only to discover that the inside was empty...there was nothing there! Indeed, most of Thames Town is empty...nothing more than a facade. One day no doubt it will fill up, but for the moment it must depend on wedding photographers and their subjects.