It is often said there are lies, damn lies, and statistics. Here's a wonderful example.
The Tyee's David Beers recently asked me to comment on this The Fraser Institute study which concluded that the ratio of construction cost to sales price of a single-family house in Vancouver is dramatically higher than in the rest of the country, including Toronto. When I took a closer look I discovered why. The authors appear to have used incorrect data.
For example, they quote the construction cost of building a new house in Vancouver in 2025 at $608,161. But they report the same house in Toronto cost $1,114,454. That's absurd. Especially since Altus's latest cost report reveals the average construction cost for a Vancouver production single-family house is $200-$320 psf, a bit higher than Toronto $200-$275 psf.
When it comes to the average new home sales prices, the researchers used $1,680,508 for Toronto and $2,881,390 for a comparable house in Vancouver. This too is wrong. While they claim the disparity was attributed in part to Vancouver's cost of government regulations, taxes and fees. Toronto generally has higher upfront municipal development charges for single-family houses than Vancouver.
While our land costs are higher, they are not $1.2 millon more.
I believe this The Fraser Institute study is seriously flawed. Part of the problem may be that it is comparing apples and oranges. (ie Westside Vancouver and Scarborough). But to conclude that the ratio between the sales price and construction cost in Vancouver is 4.7 while it is only 2.0 in Toronto is highly questionable. Was there an agenda?




No comments:
Post a Comment