During the past year, I was often asked what I thought would happen to Vancouver’s housing market. My response was simple. There is no Vancouver housing market.
There is a downtown highrise market which differs from the
Fraser Valley townhouse market. Similarly, there are rental housing markets and
ownership markets catering to first-time buyers, move-up buyers and last-time
buyers.
That said, industry associations and experts often
generalize about overall sales, housing starts and prices.
At the end of 2024, the B.C. Real Estate Association (BCREA)
predicted realtors would enjoy a 13 per cent sales jump in 2025 driven by lower
mortgage rates and government policies. Prices were expected to rise modestly.
However, due to U.S. President Donald Trump’s sweeping
tariffs announced in early February, it soon became apparent sales were falling
far short of expectations and BCREA revised its outlook.
It is now estimated that 2025 will be the year during which
the Lower Mainland experienced the lowest number of home sales this century.
While home sales dropped off significantly here, it was even
worse in Toronto. In October, only twenty-five new condominiums were sold in
the city. To put this in perspective, it is less than the number of players on
the unforgettable Toronto Blue Jays baseball team.
Trump’s tariffs also impacted new housing starts. In January
2025, MLA Canada, one of B.C.’s most successful project marketing firms,
predicted 125 condominium projects would launch across the Lower Mainland.
However, by year end, MLA tracked only forty-nine launches,
sixty per cent below their forecast and only half the Lower Mainland’s ten-year
average. However, some of these were subsequently put on hold or converted to
rental.
MLA has not issued a 2026 forecast. However, it expects that
the coming year could look a lot like last year. For one thing, investors are
almost non-existent due to declining rents and a plethora of government
policies that discourage investment.
Furthermore, Rennie Intelligence, estimates there could be
3,400 completed and unsold condominiums on the market by year end, and many
more thousands still under construction but not yet sold.
In 2026, thousands of purpose-built rental units are also
scheduled for completion which could further bring down rents. While this is
good news for renters, it is bad news for developers.
Dozens of other condominium and rental projects have
approvals in place but are not proceeding since they are no longer financially
viable. This is due to a low level of consumer confidence, excessive municipal
fees and high interest and construction costs.
To encourage some of these projects to get underway,
Vancouver recently agreed to a myriad of measures that include reductions in
development fees and engineering requirements, and deferred payments of fees.
I agree with this approach, since fees charged to
condominium developers are usually passed on to new homeowners. It seems
misguided to expect those who do not own homes to finance the costs of growth,
rather than those who already own homes. Especially since based on 2021 Census
data analyzed by SFU’s Andy Yan, nearly 50 per cent of
Vancouver homeowners have no mortgage.
While condominium living offers many benefits, people moving
out of these mortgage-free single-family houses are often apprehensive about
moving into a development that might be run by a strata council whose president
may have wanted to be prime minister of Canada but ended up overseeing eighteen
townhouses.
For these reasons, I have been urging governments to make it
easier to build ‘fee-simple,’ individually owned townhouses as an alternative
to condominium townhouses. Although commonplace in Toronto and elsewhere around
the world, they are rarely developed here.
The same applies to duplexes. Many people buy a duplex
without realizing they are buying into a strata development. Even though it is
made up of only two strata lots, the owners are required to abide by the rules
and regulations of the Strata Property Act.
There is a ‘fee-simple’ alternative to the duplex — a
‘semi-detached’ house — one of the most common forms of housing in the U.K. and
elsewhere around the world. But like fee-simple townhouses, they will not be
built here until municipalities make it easier to subdivide properties into
smaller lots and establish reduced permit and hook-up fees.
Now that the provincial government is aggressively mandating
small-scale, multi-unit housing throughout the province, fee-simple townhouses
and semi-detached homes could be attractive alternatives to strata-titled four-
and six-unit multiplexes.
Although fee-simple townhouses did not become popular in
2025, another type of housing which I have often promoted in these year-end
columns did finally gain popularity. I refer to factory-built modular housing
which was recognized by Prime Minister Mark Carney as an effective way to build
new homes.
While we will not likely see the 4,000 modular home starts
promised by the Prime Minister, I agree with him and federal Housing Minister
Gregor Robertson that factory production offers many benefits in terms of
construction quality, speed of erection and cost effectiveness.
I would like to conclude with something completely
different.
Last year, several reports surfaced linking reduced
fertility rates to a lack of suitably designed and affordable family housing.
The result was that Canada’s fertility rate hit a new record low of 1.25 children per woman. This
did not surprise me.
For years, young couples have told me they were not having
children because they could not afford family friendly two- or three-bedroom
apartments. While a house with a basement mortgage-helper would be perfect,
that was completely out of their price range.
To address this concern, twenty-five years ago during the
planning of SFU’s UniverCity community, I proposed designing apartments with a
second or third bedroom with its own door to the corridor that could serve as a
basement suite equivalent.
Initially, the suite could be rented out as a
mortgage-helper. Over time, as the family grew, it would revert to a second or
third bedroom.
Fortunately, the City of Burnaby agreed to change its zoning
so that a percentage of the apartments could include these lock-off suites.
Former Tyee journalist Monte Paulsen, who sadly died in
2024, called them ‘basement suites-in-the-sky’ and they have
subsequently become quite popular. An increasing number of municipalities now
allow them.
In 2026, it is my hope that more developers will consider
incorporating lock-off suites in their apartment buildings, especially since
lenders now recognize the rental income when determining mortgage amounts. This
could allow more households to enjoy future holiday seasons with their
children.
On this happy note, my best wishes for a healthy and
prosperous 2026.
Michael Geller FCIP, RPP, MLAI, Ret. Architect AIBC is a
Vancouver-based planner and real estate consultant. He also serves on SFU’s
adjunct faculty. You can reach him at geller@sfu.ca and find his blog
at www.gellersworldtravel.blogspot.com.



No comments:
Post a Comment