Thursday, April 18, 2013

The SFU City Conversation: Where is big too big?

Where is Big TOO Big?

file
Vancouver has had periodic debates over heights of new buildings, first in downtown, then in some neighbourhoods like Mt. Pleasant. Successive councils have allowed developers to build taller buildings than zoning would otherwise allow, in trade for developers’ donations of parks, preservation of historic buildings, day care centres, recreation facilities and other public amenities.
But where is the tradeoff inappropriate? That’s the discussion around an interesting proposal on Helmcken St. at Richards St. Brenhill Developments is proposing to replace a deteriorating city social house, with a far larger social residence and other amenities, in trade for constructing a much taller residential tower than zoning now allows.
Public benefits? Too tall? To frame the discussion, we’re very pleased to host Vancouver City Councillor Raymond Louie, former planning director Brent Toderian, and architect/developer Michael Geller. Then it’s your turn. Feel free to bring your lunch.

So what did I have to say?  Here are some notes I prepared for the event.
 

“When you’re sitting in the bathtub with the hot water running, how do you know when to shout?”

I first shouted about the scale of some new Vancouver developments a year ago when I wrote a blog posting in response of a number of developments that in my opinion, as an architect and planner…were too big.  But they were often justified because they offered greater affordability or sustainability.http://gellersworldtravel.blogspot.ca/2012/03/what-hell-is-going-on-in-this-city.html


Today’s discussion was prompted in part by Tweets I posted expressing concern with a proposal for a 17.4 FSR building on Helmcken.  For those of you who don’t know what 17.4 FSR means, it’s about 3 times the permitted FSR for Downtown South or 10 times the density of the high rise district in Kerrisdale.

Now, normally I’m the one advocating for more height or density;  today I’m going to be arguing that some developments in Vancouver are being approved at heights and densities that are not justifiable in terms of context, good planning, but rather because they offer exceptional public amenities or affordable housing or both.

Put crudely, the City and other Metro municipalities occasionally approve developments at densities higher than might normally be appropriate because of the substantial CAC’s or other public benefits being offered by or extracted from the developers.

I know that Brent and Raymond are going to dismiss my concerns by assuring me that they would never approve a building that’s too large just because of the benefits…in other words…they would never allow form to follow finance….they will say they first determine an acceptable building form…then they negotiate the $$$. 

I would argue that form should follow fit, not finance!

I will confess my views on this topic are somewhat influenced by Ray Spaxman.  I recall when I was a member of the City’s Development Permit Board Advisory Panel and a proposal came forward around 1984 for a large but very plain rental building complex on the north shore of False Creek. It was argued that it should be approved because it would provide much needed housing for EXPO 86 and beyond.  I recall Jimmy Pattison, then in charge of EXPO, urging us to approve it.

I recall Spaxman questioning why we should approve a rather unattractive building on a prominent site  just because it was needed for EXPO 86 and offered rental housing.  However, if I recall correctly, the Board approved the project, but fortunately it was never built. Today, the site is occupied by 888 Beach, one of Vancouver’s best waterfront developments.

In coming here today, I acknowledge that design and planning are highly subjective.  

I also know that often it doesn’t matter whether a building is 20 storeys or 22 storeys…what matters more is what’s happening at the ground plane or the size of the floorplate…or the detailed design of the building, the materials, the balcony details and so on

As others have suggested to me, the FSR calculation is a blunt instrument.

I agree…but when I see a proposal for a 17.4 FSR building for a site on Helmcken, I start to worry…It wasn’t that long ago I was advocating for 4 or 5 FSR for the area. Have things really changed that much in two decades.

So what’s the rationale for such a high density on what is a City-owned site?  In a somewhat complex transaction, the developer is proposing a lot of social housing units and rental housing and other community benefits.  And on its own, it’s not an unattractive building….it's across from a park, but just happens to be on a small site.  

(I would add that it has a 10,300 sq.ft. floorplate and ten levels of underground parking for about 500 cars)

I had similar concerns with the PCI development at Marine and Cambie.  To my mind, it too was too big. I once expressed my concerns on Frances Bula’s blog and asked, what is the justification for the size of this complex…did the developer pay too much for the land?  Is the city seeking too many amenities?  Is there too much rental housing?

Later that day I received a confidential email from a City planner who said the answer to these questions was yes.  She wrote that she and others in planning were also uncomfortable with the scale and massing of the complex, but had essentially been instructed to make it work. 

Time will tell if our concerns were valid.

Another development that troubled me was the Rize in Mount Pleasant. Again, time will tell if my concerns are valid, but I contend that this building form was driven by the CAC package.  Now, in 20 years there will be other large buildings around it so maybe we won’t care. But for a few years to come, I predict this building will be out of scale and detract somewhat from the neighbourhood.

Two other recent examples are 1401 Comox that was approved at 5 times the permitted FSR since it was rental (I hesitate to criticize it since I admire the architects and developer) but if this had been a condo the proposed density would never have been approved…it was approved because it was rental.

I am also troubled by the new development in the 900 Block East Hastings.  It looks like 12 floors of stacked containers, so I should like it.  But it too is too big for the context.  When I asked the developer about this…a very good developer I might add, he said the city was insisting that he develop and donate, yes donate 70 social housing units as part of the zoning trade-off.  He was also having to build light industrial space.   

Well hello….the site was zoned for light industrial.  This project is over 6 FSR and it may ultimately 
be an interesting building to look at…but now others are now buying sites assuming 6 FSR will be approved for them too. I worry what this area will look like with a parade of 6 FSR developments.

Furthermore, if 6 FSR is considered appropriate along East Hastings, why isn’t it acceptable everywhere?   

Arthur Erickson once said something in a radio interview that is quite germane to this conversation.  He said it was important for any new development to relate to its surroundings.  When the interviewer noted the surroundings will likely change over time, Erickson agreed, but added future buildings will relate to his building and change will happen incrementally. 

I support an incremental approach to increasing heights and density. But that’s not what’s happening…just look around 70th and Granville or along Kingsway…these new developments do not relate to their surroundings…but they each offered a package of community amenities, rental housing, social housing, or cash that the City found too hard to refuse. 

Last year the City received $180 million from developers in return for site rezonings. Many people will say that’s great, it means taxes didn’t go up so much…but I still worry that we’re letting housing affordability, and CAC packages drive building forms that may ultimately detract from the design quality of our city that we have enjoyed for so many decades. 

Form should follow fit, not finance.


44 comments:

Anonymous said...

Hey would you mind letting me know which hosting company you're working with? I've loaded your blog in 3 completely different web browsers and I
must say this blog loads a lot faster then most. Can you suggest
a good hosting provider at a honest price? Cheers, I appreciate it!


Visit my blog post: Build muscle

Anonymous said...

I am actually delighted to glance at this webpage posts which carries plenty of useful facts, thanks for providing such
statistics.

Here is my blog :: Nitric Power Reviews

Anonymous said...

Hi there, i read your blog occasionally and i own a similar one and i was
just wondering if you get a lot of spam comments? If
so how do you reduce it, any plugin or anything you can recommend?

I get so much lately it's driving me insane so any assistance is very much appreciated.

Feel free to visit my blog ... Slim Helper Diet

Anonymous said...

If you desire to increase your experience only keep visiting this website and be updated with the newest information posted here.


My homepage: Garcinia Cambogia benefits

Anonymous said...

Hi there, all is going sound here and ofcourse every one is sharing data, that's actually excellent, keep up writing.

Feel free to surf to my web-site: order acai ultra lean

Anonymous said...

Thanks very interesting blog!

Review my blog post ... Anatomy X5 Review

Anonymous said...

Just want to say your article is as surprising.
The clearness to your submit is simply spectacular and i could think you're an expert in this subject. Fine together with your permission let me to clutch your feed to stay updated with imminent post. Thank you 1,000,000 and please continue the gratifying work.

My web page ... Lean muscle x review

Anonymous said...

You really make it seem so easy with your presentation but I find this matter to
be really something that I think I would never understand.
It seems too complex and very broad for me. I'm looking forward for your next post, I'll try to get the hang of it!


Stop by my web site: Idrotherapy

Anonymous said...

Excellent article. I will be experiencing a few of these issues as well.
.

Here is my webpage ... Asphalt Driveway Minnesota

Anonymous said...

Wonderful, what a website it is! This website provides helpful facts to us, keep it up.



Visit my blog post; Diet Patch

Anonymous said...

Thanks for ones marvelous posting! I seriously
enjoyed reading it, you can be a great author.

I will make certain to bookmark your blog and will eventually come
back sometime soon. I want to encourage yourself
to continue your great job, have a nice holiday weekend!

Feel free to surf to my webpage ... Swiss rose reviews

Anonymous said...

Hmm is anyone else having problems with the pictures on this blog loading?
I'm trying to find out if its a problem on my end or if it's the blog.
Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated.

Feel free to surf to my web site; Buy liposom

Anonymous said...

Hi! I just wanted to ask if you ever have any problems with hackers?

My last blog (wordpress) was hacked and I ended up
losing several weeks of hard work due to no back
up. Do you have any methods to prevent hackers?


Here is my web-site Buy sytropin

Anonymous said...

bookmarked!!, I like your web site!

My webpage Ripped Muscle Xtreme

Anonymous said...

Hiya! Quick question that's completely off topic. Do you know how to make your site mobile friendly? My web site looks weird when viewing from my iphone 4. I'm trying to find a theme or plugin that might be able to resolve this issue.
If you have any suggestions, please share. Thank you!


Visit my blog - Online Payday Loans

Anonymous said...

I do not even know the way I ended up here, however I thought this put up was great.
I don't understand who you might be however certainly you're going
to a famous blogger in case you aren't already. Cheers!

Also visit my web-site - pothiq.com

Anonymous said...

Thank you for the good writeup. It in fact was a amusement account it.

Look advanced to far added agreeable from you! However, how can we communicate?


Also visit my webpage - muscle building

Anonymous said...

I loved as much as you will receive carried
out right here. The sketch is attractive, your authored material stylish.
nonetheless, you command get bought an shakiness over that you wish be delivering the following.
unwell unquestionably come more formerly again since exactly the same nearly very often inside case you shield this hike.



Also visit my website Anatomy X5 Review

Anonymous said...

Fantastic web site. Lots of helpful information here.

I am sending it to a few pals ans also sharing in
delicious. And naturally, thanks on your effort!

Look at my web-site :: Ripped Muscle X

Anonymous said...

Peculiar article, just what I was looking for.

Visit my weblog :: Beta Force Muscle Solution

Anonymous said...

Magnificent site. Plenty of useful information here.
I'm sending it to several pals ans additionally sharing in delicious. And certainly, thank you to your effort!

Also visit my webpage Muscle BUilding Supplements

Anonymous said...

Have you ever thought about creating an e-book or guest authoring on
other blogs? I have a blog centered on the same subjects
you discuss and would really like to have you share some stories/information.
I know my subscribers would value your work.
If you're even remotely interested, feel free to shoot me an email.

Also visit my web blog ... Snow Plowing MN

Anonymous said...

I have read so many articles or reviews regarding the blogger
lovers however this article is truly a nice article, keep it up.


Feel free to surf to my weblog - best muscle gainer supplement

Anonymous said...

Hi, i think that i saw you visited my weblog so
i came to “return the favor”.I am attempting to find things to enhance my website!
I suppose its ok to use a few of your ideas!
!

Here is my page ... Lean muscle x and test force xtreme

Anonymous said...

Howdy! This is my 1st comment here so I just wanted to
give a quick shout out and tell you I genuinely enjoy reading through your articles.
Can you recommend any other blogs/websites/forums that go over the same topics?

Thanks a lot!

my blog post Muscle Xtreme

Anonymous said...

Excellent items from you, man. I have have in mind your
stuff prior to and you are simply too magnificent. I actually like what you have bought right here, really like what
you are stating and the way in which wherein you are saying it.
You make it entertaining and you continue to care for to keep it smart.
I can't wait to read far more from you. That is actually a wonderful site.

Feel free to surf to my web site ... Ripped Muscle Xtreme

Anonymous said...

What i don't understood is if truth be told how you are no longer really much more neatly-appreciated than you may be now. You're so intelligent.
You recognize therefore considerably when it comes to this matter, made me personally consider it
from so many varied angles. Its like men and women aren't fascinated unless it's something to accomplish with Lady gaga!
Your individual stuffs outstanding. Always take care of it up!


Feel free to visit my web site; Pure garciniacambogia review ()

Anonymous said...

I always spent my half an hour to read this web site's articles or reviews daily along with a mug of coffee.

Feel free to visit my web page ... Order Garcinia Cambogia

Anonymous said...

Thank you for another informative blog. The place else could I get that kind
of information written in such an ideal approach?
I have a project that I'm just now running on, and I've been
at the look out for such info.

My web page: Xtrasize Review ()

Anonymous said...

I rarely write comments, but I read a few of the responses on this page "The SFU City Conversation: Where is big too big?".
I actually do have a couple of questions for you if you do not mind.
Is it simply me or do some of the responses
come across like they are written by brain dead individuals?
:-P And, if you are writing at additional online sites,
I'd like to follow anything new you have to post. Would you make a list of all of all your social sites like your linkedin profile, Facebook page or twitter feed?

My site ... Test Force Extreme

Anonymous said...

Hello friends, good piece of writing and pleasant arguments commented at this place, I am actually enjoying by these.


Also visit my web blog Garcinia Cambogia Weight Loss

Anonymous said...

Hi there! I know this is kinda off topic nevertheless I'd figured I'd ask.
Would you be interested in exchanging links or maybe guest
writing a blog article or vice-versa? My website discusses a lot of the same topics as yours and
I feel we could greatly benefit from each other.
If you're interested feel free to send me an email. I look forward to hearing from you! Superb blog by the way!

http://www.pitarticle.com/submit.php

Feel free to visit my website; Max Thermo Burn Muscle reviews

Anonymous said...

I think the admin of this web page is truly working hard for his
site, for the reason that here every material is quality based data.


my webpage - Power Precision Reviews

Anonymous said...

These are truly wonderful ideas in regarding blogging.
You have touched some good points here. Any way keep up wrinting.


Check out my web-site - muscle x

Anonymous said...

We are a group of volunteers and opening a new scheme in our community.

Your website offered us with useful info to work on. You have performed a formidable job and our whole community will be grateful to you.


Also visit my page Erica

Anonymous said...

Hi, I do believe this is a great blog. I stumbledupon it ;) I am going to return yet again since I book-marked
it. Money and freedom is the best way to change,
may you be rich and continue to help other people.




http://www.wkstationery.com/Shownews.asp?id=3492

my page - buy testostrong

Anonymous said...

You ought to take part in a contest for one of the best
websites online. I will highly recommend this website!


Also visit my webpage: cheap legal highs

Anonymous said...

Howdy! This blog post couldn't be written any better! Reading through this post reminds me of my previous roommate! He always kept preaching about this. I am going to forward this article to him. Fairly certain he will have a great read. Thanks for sharing!

Check out my web page No2 maximus facts

Anonymous said...

It's very effortless to find out any matter on net as compared to books, as I found this paragraph at this web page.

My page ... http://advancedtestoboostfacts.com

Anonymous said...

Hey there! I know this is kinda off topic nevertheless I'd figured I'd ask.
Would you be interested in exchanging links or maybe guest writing a blog post or vice-versa?

My site goes over a lot of the same topics as yours and I believe we could greatly benefit from each other.

If you happen to be interested feel free to shoot me
an e-mail. I look forward to hearing from
you! Wonderful blog by the way!


http://profitbusinessathome.net/testostrong

Here is my page testosrong reviews

Anonymous said...

I just could not depart your website prior to suggesting that I really loved the usual info
an individual supply on your visitors? Is gonna be again
steadily to investigate cross-check new posts

My web-site: Buy Ripped XL

Anonymous said...

Excellent web site you've got here.. It's hard to find good quality writing like yours these days.
I really appreciate people like you! Take care!!

http://alasbarricadas.org/ateneo/index.php/Usuario:LoydCulve

Here is my web page ... turbo force review

Anonymous said...

Hi there! Would you mind if I share your blog with my facebook group?
There's a lot of folks that I think would really appreciate your content. Please let me know. Many thanks

Also visit my web-site :: best supplements for muscle growth **

Anonymous said...

Hi there colleagues, its impressive piece of writing concerning teachingand
fully defined, keep it up all the time.

Feel free to visit my site - musclerevxfacts.com