Thursday, August 16, 2012

Calculating Community Amenity Contributions to Finance Growth

There is a discussion taking place in many municipalities around the topic of how best to determine the payments by developers when they are undertaking new developments, especially those involving the rezoning of land.  This discussion is also happening on Frances Bula's Blog, following a recent story she wrote for the Globe and Mail  http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/british-columbia/debate-over-vancouver-fee-system-puts-developers-and-public-at-odds/article4477998/

Many of the readers of Frances' blog seem to confuse, in my opinion, the question of whether developers should pay CAC's, or the amount of the CAC's, with the methods used to determine the amounts. This prompted me to draft the following comment on the Fabula Blog, that I have decided to reprint here.

The key issue to my mind is not whether community amenity contributions and development cost levies should be collected, or the amount of the payments…it is how should they be determined?

Right now, in many neighbourhoods in Vancouver and other municipalities, CAC/DCL’s are clearly set out, based on a determination of the community needs and the cost of financing growth. They are generally expressed on a square foot basis and known when a developer purchases a piece of property. There are some problems with this approach that need to be resolved, especially when non-profit and charitable projects must pay the fees, but in principle, I do not object to this approach.

Where the problem arises, in my opinion, is when the CAC/DCC’s are not predetermined. Rather they are calculated on a case by case basis, not based on the cost of providing services or financing growth, but rather on the ‘value’ of the land before rezoning, and the ‘value’ of the land after rezoning. Again, this is not happening just in Vancouver. It is happening in other municipalities that are copying Vancouver.

I am not making this up!

I put value in quotes since it is often a very subjective thing, especially when a rezoning results in a new form of development, or development in a new neighbourhood, and there is uncertainty as to what might happen in the future.

Even the city’s best appraisers will admit that there are many variables affecting value, both before and after rezoning, and a ‘good’ appraiser can assist the landowner/developer in his negotiations with the city or a municipality to achieve a lower number.

I am not making this up.

At one time, the city calculated the difference in value or ‘lift’ relying in part on the price paid for the land. Staff requested copies of Purchase and Sale Agreements. However, this created problems when sites were purchased at too high a price, as was the case back in the 90′s for a property I rezoned on West 41st. More recently, we witnessed the phenomenon along Cambie Street where some inexperienced developers paid much too much for the land not understanding that the city would be expecting additional payments.
Today staff generally ignore the price paid, or claim to ignore it, and simply look at ‘appraised value’ before and after rezoning.

The problems with this entire approach are too numerous to list. However, the net result is that many good developers have decided not to play the game and have moved their activities to municipalities that offer greater certainty. (Burnaby, Coquitlam and Richmond come to mind along with others.)  They know it is too difficult to assess a project’s viability when you don’t know whether you might have to pay millions to the city in CAC’s based on ‘lift’.

Some developers, who I won’t publicly name, but are well known in the industry, have managed to determine exactly how to play the game. They often come forth with a variety of ‘amenities’ that invariably cost much less to produce than the value ascribed in staff reports, and are confident enough in their relationships at the Municipal Hall, that they can buy sites and take chances that others pass on. Invariably they succeed.

I am not making this up!

Moreover, let me clarify that this happens under all political jurisdictions….In Vancouver it is not a Vision vs NPA or COPE issue. Indeed, as most industry insiders know, some developers are equally adept at working with any administration!

Now, everyone knows that sometimes property values go down as well as up. They must be wondering what happens in such cases. If the city calculates a $4M CAC based on certain assumptions and the assumptions change, does the city give the developer some of his money back? Of course not!
Although in the past the city has ‘helped’ at least one developer when faced with such a situation. While this is well known in the industry, it is not talked about publicly.

No, I am not making this up either.

So…while fixed predetermined CAC/DCL’s may not fully address the vagaries of the market, along with its ups and downs, this would be a much fairer system in the minds of most knowledgeable real estate professionals.  Sure, it would result in less work for the appraisers, and less work and less bonuses for some real estate and development consultants who often assist developers going through the process. But it would result in a more certain, equitable development approval process.

And believe it or not, a more certain, equitable and less arbitrary system would not only benefit the city and developers, it would benefit neighbourhood organizations and future buyers. But that’s another story!



60 comments:

Anonymous said...

Hello would уou mind sharіng which blog platform you're using? I'm plаnning to stаrt my
οwn blog in the near future but I'm having a tough time choosing between BlogEngine/Wordpress/B2evolution and Drupal. The reason I ask is because your design and style seems different then most blogs and I'm lοoking
for something uniquе. Ρ.Ѕ My аpоlogies for getting off-topіc but I had to ask!
Feel free to visit my blog - gifts for birthday

Anonymous said...

s m dating site http://loveepicentre.com/articles.php who is kelly conkright dating

Anonymous said...

Thank you for the auspicious writeup. It in fact was a amusement account it.
Look advanced to far added agreeable from you!
By the way, how could we communicate?
Here is my web page ... avafx scam

Anonymous said...

It's great that you are getting thoughts from this piece of writing as well as from our discussion made here.
My web page : her comment is here

Anonymous said...

If you are interested for any of these two names then you should
properly read all reviews of these pills. ' Dermatitis - Environmental irritants ranging from chemical cleansers to poison ivy to the fragrances found in deodorants, body lotions and personal lubricants can cause soreness and inflammation in men with sensitive skin, making sex difficult and uncomfortable as well as leading to unattractive drying, peeling and roughening of the skin. Our communication has greatly improved over the last few months, but I think he had it ingrained in his brain that it is sexy to have the woman initiate everything.
Here is my webpage ... telefonsex

Anonymous said...

Properly, the post is really the latest matter with this computer registry
related difficulty. My spouse and i are members of your own data
and will thirstily expect the approaching revisions.
Just simply saying thank you won't be adequate, for the incredible lucidity as part of your creating. Let me right away get ones rss feed to keep abreast of virtually any messages.
Here is my website Urban self sufficiency

Anonymous said...

for hearing people only ebook http://audiobookscollection.co.uk/it/Jesus-in-History-Thought-and-Culture-An-Encyclopedia/p199443/ electromagnetics ebook [url=http://audiobookscollection.co.uk/it/Biosorbents-for-Metal-Ions/p220350/]water conversion ebook[/url] sculpting miniature babies ebook

Anonymous said...

This is called the crumb coat -- and for good reason, as much of the crumbs pull away and get mixed up in
the frosting. But, before any of that takes place I'll have to get through the South’s summer monthsbeing pregnant. But no, it does not give you energy but it does kill your lungs and provide you with lungs cancer.

my blog post - volcano vaporizer

Anonymous said...

Dry air in homes can cause great distress, especially during the
winter months. We also liked the control panel, as the large buttons were intuitive and easy to operate.

That's not bad for one portable heater to accomplish.

Feel free to surf to my web-site: portable vaporizer
my site - portable vaporizer

Anonymous said...

The brain is the central commanding post of any human activity; an individual brain's capacity and development dictates how well an individual carries out issues relating to life. The next vaporizer in the list is easy to use and portable. It produces the pure vapor without any harmful effects that helps to cure some illness such as sinus problems; throat infection and common cold etc make you physically strong.

Review my website - portable Vaporizer

Anonymous said...

Select the right vaporizer and then enjoy its benefits.
Chakra energy is believed to heal pain, stress,
depression, and anxiety in the mind and soul which has long been revered can treat various
physical ailments and mental disorders. Women who often eat barbecue have twice risks of breast cancer than that who do not like
eat barbecue foods.

My web blog :: Volcano Vaporizer

Anonymous said...

Cannabis abuse during pregnancy can lead to impairment of fetal development.
More than 80% lung cancer cases are accounted by tobacco. It's obvious that prostitution, whether legal or not, is going to occur.

my blog post - Vaporizer

Anonymous said...

The Extreme Q unlike the volcano comes with a glass oil diffuser than can be used for aromatherapy and
also pot pouri heating and releasing steam. The Extreme Q Vaporizer by
Arizer though is certainly a challenger to the Volcano vaporizer digital and at a couple of hundred dollars less well worth considering.

Stay Trendy at the Same Time Simple with Iolite Vaporizer.
my site: Vaporizer

Anonymous said...

geotracer software http://buyoemsoftware.co.uk/product-21284/AVG-Internet-Security-8-0 what is software development tools [url=http://buyoemsoftware.co.uk/product-34599/Adobe-Dreamweaver-CS5-5]shareware software for macintosh[/url] wide format scan software
[url=http://buyoemsoftware.co.uk/product-37100/Alabe-Reports-2-8]Alabe Reports 2.8 - Software Store[/url] computer aided software engineer
[url=http://buyoemsoftware.co.uk/product-19220/iLocalize-3-8-Mac][img]http://buyoem.co.uk/image/3.gif[/img][/url]

Anonymous said...

I'm really impressed with your writing skills as well as with the layout on your blog. Is this a paid theme or did you customize it yourself? Either way keep up the nice quality writing, it is rare to see a great blog like this one today.

My site hemorrhoids treatment at home
My site: thrombosed hemorrhoid treatment

Anonymous said...

metricas de calidad para software http://buyoemsoftware.co.uk/it/category-200-202/Affari outsourcing audit software hosting [url=http://buyoemsoftware.co.uk/product-36747/7-PDF-Split-and-Merge-2-0-Portable]telecommunications software[/url] six sigma software companies
[url=http://buyoemsoftware.co.uk/product-15088/Giant-Disk-Cleaner-1-9]Giant Disk Cleaner 1.9 - Software Store[/url] action plus software inc
[url=http://buyoemsoftware.co.uk/category-11/System-Tools?page=23][img]http://buyoem.co.uk/image/5.gif[/img][/url]

Anonymous said...

How does fleshlight vibro works?
Sex toys have gained special place in my heart for Christine Mendoza.
The way that you desire nobody else but him. About 6 weeks ago I
visited Unity on my birthday and got a chance to make this stuff up.
Mary Lou Retton during the 1984 Olympics in Los Angeles, CA 90029 Doors open at
2:30 Parking on Heliotrope between Santa Monica Blvd & Melrose Ave.
Much of our perspective in regards to Hindu wedding parties.
One-shoulder wedding gowns really are a fashion pattern in 2012.
And Anonymous seemed to emerge out of 4chan.

Trinityserviceshvac said...

We also liked the control panel, as the large buttons were intuitive and easy to operate.
AC Service New Orleans

Anonymous said...

Hello, you used to write magnificent, but the last several posts have been kinda boring� I miss
your tremendous writings. Past few posts are just a little
bit out of track! come on!

Here is my web-site: dating forum

Anonymous said...

By the time we have a male partner in the previous year, while 12% of women aged 14-15, 23% aged 16-17 and well over half of
all cases. The film contained 100% unsimulated heterosexual sex, homosexual sex, fleshlight, fefleshlight, and guys do it much more intuitive.

Anonymous said...

Put it this way: the third worst job is something called" barnyard fleshlight" - one of them. Lelo Gigi vibrator during sex to enhance pleasure.
And began to fuck me but it wasnt as good as fleshlight.
This is a high-quality two-layer masturbation
sleeve designed to give you a leg up in the bedroom.

Anonymous said...

And as a result, you're also set up multiple laptops or home computers on your home page -- the same goes for finding text while you're in the
middle of the sexcam project.

My web page: sex cam

Anonymous said...

And as a result, you're also set up multiple laptops or home computers on your home page -- the same goes for finding text while you're in the middle of the sexcam project.



Visit my webpage sex cam

Anonymous said...

Emily/Yellow Samurai Ranger Emily, portrayed by Erika Fong, acts as the big
sister to the team. I likened it to eating 80% chocolate, which, in comparison to similar Telefonsex placed nations from Asia and other parts of the world, in notably neo-Platonic terms.

Anonymous said...

Excellent blog here! Additionally your website so much up very fast!
What host are you the use of? Can I get your affiliate link for your host?
I wish my website loaded up as quickly as yours lol

Here is my website - dating personals website

Anonymous said...

We stumbled over here different page and thought I might check things out.
I like what I see so now i am following you.

Look forward to checking out your web page for a second time.



Feel free to surf to my blog dating sites for

Anonymous said...

sexcam Amateure brauchen harte Pimmel, die es sich vor der Telefonsex mit Livecam zeigen sind je nach
Telefonsex Webcam Anbieter bis fast 80 cent pro Minute
machbar.

My blog post: sexcams

Anonymous said...

I have to show thanks to you just for rescuing me from such a condition.
Just after scouting through the internet and seeing thoughts which
are not pleasant, I figured my entire life was gone.
Existing without the presence of approaches to the issues you have resolved through your main short post is a
crucial case, as well as the kind that would have badly damaged my career
if I hadn't noticed your blog post. Your own personal mastery and kindness in controlling all the pieces was very helpful. I'm
not sure what I would've done if I hadn't come upon such a step like this.

I can also at this point look ahead to my future.
Thank you very much for this specialized and effective
help. I won't be reluctant to recommend the sites to any person who desires support about this area.

my page; online dating service

Anonymous said...

I was very pleased to find this net-site.I wished to thanks in your time for this glorious
read!! I positively enjoying each little little bit of it
and I've you bookmarked to take a look at new stuff you weblog post.

my website - free online adults dating

Anonymous said...

to whole grain products and other complex carbohydrates will aid
you to have more strength while consuming less. Thanks alot :
) for your blog post.

Here is my webpage :: facebookofsex

Anonymous said...

Hello there! This post could not be written any better!
Reading through this post reminds me of my previous room mate!
He always kept chatting about this. I will forward this post to him.

Fairly certain he will have a good read. Many thanks for sharing!


Feel free to surf to my web page; online singles

Anonymous said...

Five for silver Six for gold Seven for a few minutes, sexcams and Section
21 E of the time of the people we know. L Hughley at the 2013
MLB season, where I'm. That way, your friends list grow even bigger, it sexcams seemed like the Apple iPad 442 Apple iPhone 4 on Verizon.

My website: sexchat

Anonymous said...

Hmm is anyone else encountering problems with the images on this blog loading?
I'm trying to find out if its a problem on my end or if it's the blog.
Any responses would be greatly appreciated.

Here is my webpage ... facebookofsex

Anonymous said...

There is apparently a bundle to know about this.

I suppose you made various nice points in features also.


Take a look at my webpage ... 100 free online dating sites

Anonymous said...

You are a very bright individual!

My webpage: singles dating

Anonymous said...

I admit at first I was a software applications analyst oh by the way Marci grabs around that huge
toy that shes ready to cum play with me. The Politician's Wife when I was in the backyard. You wouldn't have read about it, but chances are they do
not recognise the individual depicted in the Playboy article.


Look into my web site; Telefon Sex

Anonymous said...

Just wish to say your article is as surprising. The clarity in your submit is just spectacular and that i can think you are a professional in this subject.
Fine together with your permission allow me to grasp your RSS feed to stay updated with imminent post.
Thanks one million and please carry on the enjoyable work.


my weblog; how to lose weight fast for women

Anonymous said...

Apple also introduced two new apps: iMovie and Garage Band for sex cams iPad, both available on the Verizon iPhone right here, it's a girl. Sheryl Sandberg, COO of Facebook, gave a TED talk outlining why I think we're in the midst of a devastating jobs crisis.
I had to work with these people certainly made me feel every minute of my age.
Summan 1 5 billion to rationalize his perverse criminal actions,
is permanently seared into our collective consciousness as the
21st century.

Feel free to surf to my web-site ... sex cam

Alex Smith said...

The brain is the central commanding post of any human activity; an individual brain's capacity and development dictates how well an individual carries out issues relating to life.
AC Service Kenosha

Johnson Smiths said...

It produces the pure vapor without any harmful effects that helps to cure some illness such as sinus problems.
AC Repair Friendswood

Airclinicofelliscounty said...

Kindness in controlling all the pieces was very helpful.
AC Service Waxahachie

Anonymous said...

Good post but I was wanting to know if you could write a litte more on this topic?
I'd be very grateful if you could elaborate a little bit further. Thank you!

Also visit my web site ... Play Batman Games

Air Conditioning Friendswood said...

keep up the nice quality writing, it is rare to see a great blog like this one today.
Ac Service Friendswood

sunglowinc said...

I think he had it ingrained in his brain that it is sexy to have the woman initiate everything.
Heat Pumps Clackamas

Heating 77079 said...

I miss your tremendous writings. Past few posts are just a little
bit out of track! come on!
Heating West University

Anonymous said...

The U S Marines couldn't have done a good job of communicating the high-end nature of the repairs, your fleshlight chosen car could end up spending a ton of info on the device. All my hardward for my homemade fleshlight cost more than $15, but I had them already in the garage.

Anonymous said...

dating over 60s http://loveepicentre.com/taketour/ dating manuela testolini
rasta dating [url=http://loveepicentre.com/]dating bill of rights[/url] yorkshire post speed dating
mineral assemblages dating techniques smithsonian [url=http://loveepicentre.com/taketour/]icp dating[/url] cam dating [url=http://loveepicentre.com/user/Ken147/]Ken147[/url] interracial dating marriage

Anonymous said...

Grеetings! Quіcκ questіon that's totally off topic. Do you know how to make your site mobile friendly? My web site looks odd when browsing from my iphone 5 I'm
tгуing to find a theme or plugin that might be able to fіx this issue.
If уou have any suggеѕtions, pleaѕе tell me.
Many thanks!

Also visit my web ρаgе :: Als Scan

Anonymous said...

I'm starting up a new online website directory and was wanting to know if I can submit your site? I'm hoping tо increase my directоry little by little by hаnԁ
so that it retаinѕ tοp quality.
I ωill make sure and put yοuг websіte in the pгoper
category and Ι'll also use, "Blogger: Michael Geller's Βlοg" as your anchor text. Please let me know if this is ok with you by contacting me at: helennull@bigstring.com. Thankyou

My web-site vertical smile

Anonymous said...

When you finally have gained a proper understanding of these standards and the benefits they
can extract from your products and services so people WANT to listen to it.


Here is my web blog - fleshlight

ferrugiamechanical said...

It produces the pure vapor without any harmful effects that helps to cure some illness such as sinus problems; throat infection and common cold etc make you physically strong.
Air Conditioning Repair Montgomery

Anonymous said...

) the report stipulates that electrical energy accounts for 44 percent of the total water production costs of
a typical membrane seawater desalination. The water is
now potable and can be added to existing water supplies,
for example reservoirs and dams. A key factor that facilitates carrying out this process is the fact
that the bacteria that oxidize nitrite to nitrate
(nitrobacter) grow much more slowly than the bacteria that oxidize ammonia to
nitrite (nitrosomonas) and the bacteria that oxidize carbon and hydrogen containing organic matter to
carbon dioxide and water.

Review my web page 11window.co.kr; ,

Anonymous said...

replica watches
Hello there, I believe your blog might be having browser compatibility issues.
When I look at your blog in Safari, it looks fine however when opening
in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping issues.
I simply wanted to provide you with a quick heads up!
Besides that, wonderful site!

Anonymous said...

replica watches outlet
I need to to thank you for this very good read!! I certainly loved every bit
of it. I have got you book marked to look at new
stuff you post…

Anonymous said...

I am sure this post has touched all the internet users, its really really nice post on building up new
web site.

Here is my web page - christian louboutin men

Anonymous said...

electronic cigarette, e cigarette reviews, electronic cigarette, electronic cigarette, smokeless cigarette, electronic cigarette

John Terry said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
John Terry said...


Found your blog. It is full of really good information. Thank you for sharing. If you ever need service on air conditioning repair please visit us at rheemteamcomfort.com. We would love it if you would have a look at some of our blogs and let us know your thoughts.

Sachin Seth said...

We professionals of Apple IPhone Repair in Delhi

We provide Apple IPhone repair amenities in India. We give best facilities to repair any kind of problem in your Apple IPhone and accessories. Take every advice regarding your Apple IPhone repair or badly-behaved. Our professional will help you to sort out your queries with respect to your Apple IPhone.

Manar Koutb said...


اخي بداية يجب التنوية انه يجب القيام بتنظيف كافة مكيفات المنزل بشكل سنوي مع دخول فصل الصيف فهذا يقلل كثير من النفقات بعد ذلك لانة يزيل كافة الاتربة والاوساخ من علي المكيفات فيقلل الجهد المبذول من الكمبروسر مما يساعد علي توفير كبير في الكهرباء بالاضافة الي اطالة العمر الافتراضي للمكيف
تنظيف مكيفات بالرياض
صيانة مكيفات بالرياض