Wednesday, April 11, 2012
Sister Cities: Beneficial exchanges or just junkets?
Last week it was revealed that a number of Burnaby politicians and senior officials visited Mesa Arizona during spring break. It made front page news in the Province and many people were upset, not the least of which was Mike Smythe, Province Columnist who was also filling in for Bill Good for the past two weeks on CKNW.
Mike Smyth argued that this trip, and in fact all Sister City trips are essentially junkets with little or no payback or value. He thought it was outrageous that the Burnaby delegation would go off when taxpayers are being nickled and dimed to death. He also questioned why other politicians would travel to other places during such difficult economic times.
As someone who believes there is much to be gained from travel, I didn't agree. While I could understand why many would question the appropriateness of going to Mesa in the spring, and disagreed with the idea of spouses accompanying politicians and officials on these trips, I can see the value of Sister City relationships. This is especially true where there are obvious opportunities for information exchange or business development. For example, many Canadian cities are now 'twinned' with those in China, Japan and Korea where much can be gained.
All but nine Metro municipalities have Sister City relationships. Vancouver has a number of Sister Cities and I have visited all of them...Los Angeles, Guangzhou, Yokohama, Edinburgh and Odessa I understand the relationship with Yokohama led to Nissan's decision to launch their electric car in Vancouver. (Nissan is based in Yokohama). While I can't comment on other benefits, I do know that the Mayor of the City of North Vancouver benefitted from the relationship with a Japanese city where he learned about waste to energy incineration.
Every week, in advance of the CKNW Civic Affairs Panel, Lesli Boldt, Frances Bula and I are invited to suggest potential topics. Having heard Mike Smyth's rant, I thought this would be a good topic for us. Let's just say it was a lively conversation, and at one point I challenged the host to speak to Burnaby Mayor Corrigan about his trip. Today Corrigan appeared on the show, and gave a reasonable account of the benefits of the trip. While I suspect he didn't convince everyone on the benefits of Sister City relationships, he did win over some callers.
My concern is that if we go overboard in criticizing politicians for travel we'll get very insular politicians. There is much to be learned from travelling to other cities, especially when the trip is hosted by another city or government. In this regard, I'm pleased to say that next week I am off to the Netherlands at the invitation of the Dutch Consul General and government. I'll be blogging regularly about what I see, as well as writing some columns for the Vancouver Sun and other publications.
Next month I'm off to Korea. This time, I have not been invited by anyone; but wanted to visit the EXPO 2012 in Yeosu on the southern coast of the country. If any of you have travelled to either country and have recommendations, please let me know.