Wednesday, April 8, 2015

The French still have an Edifice Complex

It is the symbol of Paris, for good reason!
En route to a ten day trip in Morocco last month, I decided to take a side trip to Paris for 4 days. I love the city, especially the overall architectural harmony resulting from the consistent scale and use of materials in much of the city.
I stayed at L'Empire, a small boutique hotel in the 1st arrondissment very close to the Louvre. I can recommend it as a comfortable place in an excellent location with a good breakfast....although the rooms are small. www.l'empire-paris.com

Long time Vancouver planner and development consultant Chuck Brook, who now keeps a home in the south of France, joined me for 2 days. We wandered through the city, visiting his favourite spots, including Le Marais where we looked like a couple of aging North American Jews trying to dress as French men.
We also toured 2 new architectural tours de force: Jean Nouvel's still under construction Philharmonic Hall, (It strikes me as a colossal waste of money....and it's not even beautiful) and Frank Gehry's Louis Vuitton Foundation gallery. I call it a gallery but it is intended to be much more....although I'm not exactly sure what! It does have a cafe called Frank which features flying fish, fish being a Frank Gehry trademark.

Unfortunately, I inadvertently deleted most of my Paris photos, thinking I had transferred them to the Microsoft Surface that I took on this trip in lieu of my computer. The Surface then crashed after Chuck transferred some of his photos, so this and subsequent blogs are being written after the fact. However, I hope you enjoy some of the photos, and appreciate why I am delighted there is now a non-stop Air France service between Vancouver and Paris.
I was astounded at how many people were shopping at Printemps and Gallerie Lafayette

Why don't we have street kiosks like these? They add pedestrian interest and are very convenient.
Moulin Rouge is still there! And always will be!
The train stations in Paris are spectacular. Gare de Lyon above, Gare de Nord below
A good friend hoped he would see some good photos of French food. Here's my souffle
I have always been intrigued by French cars. This is Renault's latest electrical vehicle....a 2 seater (one behind the other)
In addition to bike-share there is now an electric car-share network of vehicles around Paris
Chutzpah! William Saurin tells you to eat fruit and vegetables to be healthy, while advertising its pate!
Chutzpah? a fellow places this yellow card on the seats in front of travellers on the train in from the airport
Whenever I can, I take a river/water cruise in every city I visit. Why don't we have more readily available cruises around the waterways in Vancouver?
I love this...he has his own amphibious car on his barge!
I would have thought the Brigitte Bardot would be a more beautiful, curvilinear boat!
I watched these Chinese tourists (and there were a lot of Chinese tourists in Paris) taking dozens of selfies as we cruised down the Seine
On my return to Paris before catching the inaugural non-stop flight to Vancouver, I took Chuck's advice and stayed at the CitizenM hotel at Charles de Gaulle airport. It was very impressive.
The rooms are small, very small, but state-of-the-art from a technological point of view. From a bedside tablet you control everything, including the mood lighting!


I completed my trip with a night-time cruise along the Seine
It offered an opportunity to see what is described as the smallest building in Paris. (I suspect they mean the narrowest in the city)


Nice touch. French attendants greet passengers on the inaugural non-stop Air France service to Vancouver.

Monday, April 6, 2015

Opinion: Art reflects life in the Downtown Eastside March 10, 2015



Art reflects life in the Downtown Eastside
Michael Geller / Vancouver Courier
March 10, 2015 02:40 PM
 

As I listened to an Elections B.C. official describe the voting process for the forthcoming plebiscite a single thought came to mind: I hope we never have to go through this again.
What a colossal disaster this is turning out to be. Thanks, Christy.

As the ballots are about to be mailed out, I have decided to again leave town. This time I am off to Paris and Morocco in search of more planning ideas to share at a forthcoming lecture entitled 12 Great Ideas for Vancouver from Around the World. It will be presented at SFU Harbour centre on April 1.

But before I leave, I am participating in an art unveiling and panel discussion at 6 p.m. tonight (March 11) at Vancouver Community College’s downtown campus. It is organized by the Vancouver Biennale, a non-profit charitable organization that celebrates art in public spaces. It brings to Vancouver the works by internationally renowned and emerging contemporary artists that most people actually like.

I agreed to participate in this event since the installation by artist Toni Latour titled “Let’s Heal the Divide” is intended to provoke discussion about the divide that has long existed between the Downtown Eastside and the rest of the city.

For many years, I have been concerned with how little progress has been made in the Downtown Eastside despite the million dollars a day being spent on social services.

Tonight’s panel, to be moderated by SFU’s Gordon Price, includes Sandra Seekins, a faculty member in art history at Capilano University, and Romi Chandra Herbert, co-executive director of PeerNetBC. Panelists are being asked to address the question whether art can be a catalyst for social change.

To my mind, there is no doubt that art and artists can be positive agents of change, which is why I was pleased SFU’s Centre for Contemporary Arts decided to move into the Downtown Eastside.
While at the time Jim Green and others worried an art school might lead to undesired neighbourhood gentrification, I was confident it could help regenerate what most regard as a very tragic part of the city.

I say “most” since some Downtown Eastside community activists do not share my view that this neighbourhood is in desperate need of repair.

While they urge the city to replace single room occupancy hotels with 5,000 suites of social housing (and city planners seem ready to oblige), they are not as troubled as I am by deplorable streetscapes with crumbling buildings, desolate, empty storefronts and open drug dealing.

As Wendy Pedersen of the Carnegie Community Action Plan has told me on a number of occasions, if this is what it takes to keep the condo developers away, so be it.

Tonight I will acknowledge that Toni Latour’s art installation may help focus attention on the divide that exists between the Downtown Eastside and the rest of the city, but it will not do much to cause social change.

I am much more optimistic about another public art installation about to happen in Winnipeg’s inner city. As reported in Maclean’s magazine, this project by visual artist KC Adams titled “Perception” asked prominent indigenous Winnipeggers to pose for two photos: one during which they were to think negative thoughts including the racism they have suffered, and one while having happier thoughts.
 
“Perception” asked prominent indigenous Winnipeggers to pose for two photos: one during which they were to think negative thoughts including the racism they have suffered, and one while having happier thoughts. 

The artist then asked her models to label their photos, choosing words that reflect the way they are often perceived by the wider community, such as drug dealer or hooker.

Viewers are then invited to “look again” at the second photo in order to see that the “hooker” is really “a mother, daughter, girlfriend, sister, high school graduate, working mom (who) loves apples and coffee and is social assistance free.” And so on.

The artworks will appear on billboards, in storefronts and bus shelters and inaugurate an annual indigenous art project in a city long divided along racial lines.
While it will take more than public art to heal the divides in the Downtown Eastside and Winnipeg’s inner city, I believe it can play a positive role.
 Sadly the same cannot be said for TransLink’s $30,000 contribution to the Main Street poodle installation that the No side loves to ridicule. Ignore them.

© 2015 Vancouver Courier
- See more at: http://www.vancourier.com/opinion/columnists/art-reflects-life-in-the-downtown-eastside-1.1787985#sthash.DblekAn5.dpuf

Thursday, March 5, 2015

Opinion: Check your ego at the transit gate door Vancouver Courier March 4, 2015

If the transit referendum passes we could see rapid bus systems like this one in Curitiba Brazil
My interest in the forthcoming transit referendum dates back, in part, to Oct. 15, 1970 when, as a University of Toronto student, I attended the premiere screening of a The Burning Would, a documentary film made by the late Jane Jacobs and Marshall McLuhan opposing a proposed expansion of Toronto’s Spadina Expressway.

Both Jacobs and McLuhan were supposed to be at the screening but McLuhan had to cancel at the last minute. The moderator apologized for his absence and read out his speech which, as I recall, comprised three words: “Forget your ego.”

McLuhan wanted us to stop thinking about expressways and automobiles as first-class transportation and public transit as second-class.

This resonated with me since a year earlier, I had returned from 15 months working and travelling in England and Scandinavia where the image of public transit was very different than in North America.
In hindsight, it is fascinating to revisit what McLuhan had to say about city planning and transportation four and a half decades ago.

He wrote: “Our planners are 19th century men with a naïve faith in an obsolete technology. In an age of software, planners treat people like hardware — they haven’t the faintest interest in the values of neighbourhood or community. Their failure to learn from the mistakes of American cities will be ours too… The Spadina Expressway is an old hardware American dream of now dead cities and blighted communities.”

Toronto’s Stop Spadina movement was happening around the same time as the Strathcona Property Owners and Tenants Association (SPOTA) was leading the charge against a proposed expressway in Vancouver. Today, most Vancouverites would agree we have a much better city since we stopped U.S.-style freeways.
I arrived in Vancouver in 1974. Shortly thereafter, I was appointed Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation’s Special Coordinator for the redevelopment of city lands along the south shore of False Creek. Mayor Art Phillips and his council colleagues wanted to create an exemplary transit-focused, walkable community. Some streets were even restricted to pedestrians only and parking ratios were substantially reduced. The marketing tagline for the first condos was “Work in Vancouver, Live in Europe.”
To ensure B.C. Transit would provide bus service on the day the first residents moved in, a special $5 charge (per month) was levied against every unit as a subsidy. Unfortunately, the planning was ahead of its time and a parking garage was eventually built to accommodate the overflow of resident and visitor cars.
 
In the late 1980s, McLuhan’s words rang in my ears when, as president of the Urban Development Institute, I participated with then city councillor Carole Taylor on a CBC Sunday morning program discussing public transportation. I embarrassingly recall confessing that on the few occasions I used public transit, I would ask the driver in a loud voice what the fare was so that other passengers would not think of me as a regular user.
 
Today, for many motorists, public transit continues to be viewed as second-class transportation. It is not for them. I suspect this is one reason why many oppose the extra 0.5 per cent sales tax. They may fabricate other excuses such as objecting to TransLink’s CEO salary, but in reality they don’t want to pay towards a transit system that is not for them.

But for others, attitudes are definitely changing. This was best illustrated by a prominent lawyer who regularly holidays in the south of France and St. Bart’s who casually mentioned to me he and his wife now regularly take the bus downtown. They can enjoy a glass of wine with their meal and avoid exorbitant parking charges. As people who often travel to London, New York and Paris, they no longer think there’s a stigma to using Vancouver transit. Most people now using the Canada Line and SkyTrain also know this to be true.
 
Soon our referendum ballots will arrive in the mail. Before voting, I would urge you to carefully consider the real benefits offered by improved transit: substantial gas, parking, and car maintenance savings; improved health; reduced traffic congestion; and for a few of us, a reduced likelihood of being charged with DUI offences.

Marshall McLuhan was right. We should be building better transit, not expressways. So forget your ego and vote Yes.
- See more at: http://www.vancourier.com/opinion/columnists/check-your-ego-at-the-transit-gate-door-1.1780767#sthash.8VjfLpuF.dpuf
My interest in the forthcoming transit referendum dates back, in part, to Oct. 15, 1970 when, as a University of Toronto student, I attended the premiere screening of a The Burning Would, a documentary film made by the late Jane Jacobs and Marshall McLuhan opposing a proposed expansion of Toronto’s Spadina Expressway.
Both Jacobs and McLuhan were supposed to be at the screening but McLuhan had to cancel at the last minute. The moderator apologized for his absence and read out his speech which, as I recall, comprised three words: “Forget your ego.”
McLuhan wanted us to stop thinking about expressways and automobiles as first-class transportation and public transit as second-class.
This resonated with me since a year earlier, I had returned from 15 months working and travelling in England and Scandinavia where the image of public transit was very different than in North America.
In hindsight, it is fascinating to revisit what McLuhan had to say about city planning and transportation four and a half decades ago.
He wrote: “Our planners are 19th century men with a naïve faith in an obsolete technology. In an age of software, planners treat people like hardware — they haven’t the faintest interest in the values of neighbourhood or community. Their failure to learn from the mistakes of American cities will be ours too… The Spadina Expressway is an old hardware American dream of now dead cities and blighted communities.”
Toronto’s Stop Spadina movement was happening around the same time as the Strathcona Property Owners and Tenants Association (SPOTA) was leading the charge against a proposed expressway in Vancouver. Today, most Vancouverites would agree we have a much better city since we stopped U.S.-style freeways.
I arrived in Vancouver in 1974. Shortly thereafter, I was appointed Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation’s Special Coordinator for the redevelopment of city lands along the south shore of False Creek. Mayor Art Phillips and his council colleagues wanted to create an exemplary transit-focused, walkable community. Some streets were even restricted to pedestrians only and parking ratios were substantially reduced. The marketing tagline for the first condos was “Work in Vancouver, Live in Europe.”
To ensure B.C. Transit would provide bus service on the day the first residents moved in, a special $5 charge was levied against every unit as a subsidy.
Unfortunately, the planning was ahead of its time and a parking garage was eventually built to accommodate the overflow of resident and visitor cars.
In the late 1980s, McLuhan’s words rang in my ears when, as president of the Urban Development Institute, I participated with then city councillor Carole Taylor on a CBC Sunday morning program discussing public transportation.
I embarrassingly recall confessing that on the few occasions I used public transit, I would ask the driver in a loud voice what the fare was so that other passengers would not think of me as a regular user.
Today, for many motorists, public transit continues to be viewed as second-class transportation. It is not for them. I suspect this is one reason why many oppose the extra 0.5 per cent sales tax. They may fabricate other excuses such as objecting to TransLink’s CEO salary, but in reality they don’t want to pay towards a transit system that is not for them.
But for others, attitudes are definitely changing. This was best illustrated by a prominent lawyer who regularly holidays in the south of France and St. Bart’s who casually mentioned to me he and his wife now regularly take the bus downtown. They can enjoy a glass of wine with their meal and avoid exorbitant parking charges. As people who often travel to London, New York and Paris, they no longer think there’s a stigma to using Vancouver transit.
Most people now using the Canada Line and SkyTrain also know this to be true.
Soon our referendum ballots will arrive in the mail. Before voting, I would urge you to carefully consider the real benefits offered by improved transit: substantial gas, parking, and car maintenance savings; improved health; reduced traffic congestion; and for a few of us, a reduced likelihood of being charged with DUI offences.
Marshall McLuhan was right. We should be building better transit, not expressways. So forget your ego and vote Yes.
michaelarthurgeller@gmail.com
twitter.com/michaelgeller
- See more at: http://www.vancourier.com/opinion/columnists/check-your-ego-at-the-transit-gate-door-1.1780767#sthash.8VjfLpuF.dpuf